# US Dividend Withholding Tax In A TFSA Vs RRSP

> US dividends usually lose 15% to US withholding tax in a TFSA, but not in an RRSP. Here's how the Canada-US tax treaty treats each account, with a worked example. From the Maple Budget handbook, Investing Basics. Updated 2026-11-17. Facts checked 2026-11-17. Web page: https://maplebudget.com/learn/us-dividend-withholding-tax/

When a US company pays you a dividend, the US usually withholds 15% before it reaches your account. In an RRSP, US stocks and US-listed ETFs are generally exempt, so nothing is withheld. In a TFSA, the 15% is withheld and you can't get it back. In a non-registered account, it's withheld but you can usually claim it as a foreign tax credit on your Canadian return.

## What It Is

Countries tax income earned inside their borders. When a US company pays dividends to someone outside the US, it withholds tax at source and sends it to the IRS. The default rate is 30%.

The Canada-US tax treaty lowers that. Under Article X, the US can withhold no more than 15% of the dividend in most cases. A lower 5% rate applies only to a company that owns at least 10% of the voting stock, so 15% is the rate for individual investors. Your broker applies the treaty rate once you've signed a W-8BEN form.

The treaty also has Article XXI, which exempts dividends and interest earned by plans set up to provide pension and retirement benefits. Brokers' guides, like Questrade's, explain that the IRS treats RRSPs and RRIFs as retirement plans under this part. TFSAs, FHSAs and RESPs are not, even though they're tax-sheltered in Canada.

## Key Rules

- **The treaty rate is 15%.** That's the most the US can withhold on dividends to most Canadian residents.
- **RRSPs and RRIFs are usually exempt.** US stocks and US-listed ETFs held directly in an RRSP or RRIF generally have no US tax withheld on dividends.
- **TFSAs are not exempt.** The 15% is withheld, and you can't claim it back. The same goes for FHSAs and RESPs.
- **Non-registered accounts can claim a credit.** You report the full foreign dividend in Canadian dollars and can claim the federal foreign tax credit for the US tax paid, up to the Canadian tax on that income.
- **Canadian-listed ETFs are different.** If a Canadian-listed ETF holds US stocks, the fund is the one receiving the dividends. US tax is withheld inside the fund, even in an RRSP.
- **Foreign dividends don't get the dividend tax credit.** The CRA says that credit is only for dividends from taxable Canadian corporations.
- **Convert to Canadian dollars.** For a non-registered account, the CRA asks you to convert foreign income using Bank of Canada exchange rates.
- **It's about dividends, not gains.** Withholding applies to dividend payments. It doesn't apply to capital gains when you sell.

## A Worked Example

Kim lives in Ottawa and owns a US-listed ETF of US stocks. It pays her US$1,000 of dividends in a year. Here's what happens depending on where she holds it, assuming her broker has her W-8BEN on file.

**In her RRSP.** No US tax is withheld. She receives the full US$1,000 inside the account.

**In her TFSA.** 15% of US$1,000 is US$150. The US withholds it, and she receives US$850. She has no way to claim the US$150 back. Over time, that's a 15% drag on the dividend part of her return.

**In her non-registered account.** The US withholds US$150 and she receives US$850. At tax time, she reports the full US$1,000, converted to Canadian dollars, as foreign income. Then she claims the foreign tax credit for the US$150 of tax paid. If her Canadian tax on that income is at least that much, the credit offsets it, so she isn't taxed twice.

**If she held a Canadian-listed ETF of US stocks instead.** The fund itself receives the US dividends, and 15% is withheld inside the fund before anything reaches her. That's true even in her RRSP, because the treaty exemption belongs to her RRSP, not to the Canadian fund.

### Where To Hold US Investments

Putting it together, many Canadians with US holdings use their RRSP for US-listed dividend payers, since that's where the treaty exemption applies. In a non-registered account, the foreign tax credit usually prevents double tax. A TFSA is often used for Canadian holdings or growth-focused investments, where US withholding matters less.

This is about the dividend part of your return. If a holding pays little or no dividend, withholding barely matters wherever you hold it.

## Common Mistakes

- **Putting high-dividend US stocks in a TFSA by default.** The 15% you lose each year is permanent. Growth-focused holdings feel it less.
- **Assuming an RRSP fixes every fund.** The exemption works for US stocks and US-listed ETFs held directly. A Canadian-listed fund of US stocks still has withholding inside it.
- **Forgetting to claim the credit.** In a non-registered account, the foreign tax credit is how you avoid paying tax twice. Your tax slips show the foreign tax paid.
- **Letting the W-8BEN lapse.** Without a valid form on file, your broker may withhold more. Brokers usually ask you to renew it.
- **Ignoring the currency cost.** Buying US-listed ETFs to avoid withholding means converting to US dollars, which has its own cost. See [Norbert's Gambit](https://maplebudget.com/learn/us-dollars-and-norberts-gambit/).
- **Chasing a tiny saving.** On a low-dividend fund, the withholding difference may be smaller than the extra cost and effort.

## How Maple Budget Helps

Maple Finance shows your accounts by type, TFSA, RRSP, FHSA, Non-Registered, Savings or Crypto, so you can see where your US holdings sit. On the web **Dashboard**, the **Allocation** card has **Type**, **Holding** and **Currency** views. Use them to check whether your US-dollar dividend payers are in your RRSP or your TFSA. See [add your investments](https://maplebudget.com/help/add-investments/).

Maple doesn't track dividends or withholding tax yet, so use your broker's statements and tax slips at tax time. Maple Finance comes with Maple Pro, which starts with a 7-day free trial.

This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your own numbers depend on your situation, so check with the CRA or an accountant before you act.

## Common Questions

### Can I Get Back US Tax Withheld In My TFSA?

Usually not. The US doesn't treat a TFSA as a retirement plan under the treaty, and because TFSA income isn't on your Canadian return, there's no foreign tax credit to claim.

### Does The RRSP Exemption Cover Canadian-Listed ETFs Of US Stocks?

No. When a Canadian-listed ETF holds US stocks, the fund itself receives the dividends, so US tax is withheld inside the fund. The RRSP exemption applies to US stocks and US-listed ETFs held directly.

### What Is A W-8BEN?

It's a US tax form your broker asks you to sign to confirm you're not a US person. It's how your broker applies the treaty rate instead of the higher default rate.

### Do Foreign Dividends Get The Dividend Tax Credit?

No. The CRA says foreign dividends don't qualify for the dividend tax credit. In a non-registered account they're reported as foreign income, in Canadian dollars.

## Sources

- [Convention Between Canada And The United States Of America With Respect To Taxes On Income And On Capital (Department Of Finance Canada)](https://www.canada.ca/en/department-finance/programs/tax-policy/tax-treaties/country/united-states-america-convention-consolidated-1980-1983-1984-1995-1997-2007.html), checked 2026-11-17
- [Line 40500, Federal Foreign Tax Credit (CRA)](https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/individuals/topics/about-your-tax-return/tax-return/completing-a-tax-return/deductions-credits-expenses/line-40500-federal-foreign-tax-credit.html), checked 2026-11-17
- [Line 12100, Interest And Other Investment Income (CRA)](https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/individuals/topics/about-your-tax-return/tax-return/completing-a-tax-return/personal-income/line-12100-interest-other-investment-income.html), checked 2026-11-17
- [U.S. Dividend Withholding Tax By Account Type (Questrade)](https://www.questrade.com/learning/accounts-taxes/us-dividend-withholding-tax-canada), checked 2026-11-17
- [RRSP Foreign Withholding Tax (Questrade)](https://www.questrade.com/learning/accounts-taxes/rrsp-foreign-withholding-tax), checked 2026-11-17
- [Federal Income Tax And Benefit Information 2025, 5000-G (CRA)](https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/cra-arc/formspubs/pub/5000-g/5000-g-25e.pdf), checked 2026-11-17

## Related Articles

- [Holding US Dollars And Norbert's Gambit](https://maplebudget.com/learn/us-dollars-and-norberts-gambit.md): How Canadians can hold US dollars in an investment account, how Norbert's Gambit converts CAD to USD with DLR, and how to report US trades in Canadian dollars.
- [What Is A Dividend?](https://maplebudget.com/learn/what-is-a-dividend.md): A dividend is a share of a company's profits paid to shareholders, often quarterly. Here's how dividends work in Canada, how yield works and how they're taxed.
- [The Dividend Tax Credit](https://maplebudget.com/learn/dividend-tax-credit.md): The dividend tax credit cuts the tax on dividends from Canadian companies. Here's how the gross-up and the federal and Ontario credits work, with a worked example.
- [How A TFSA Works In Canada](https://maplebudget.com/learn/how-a-tfsa-works.md): A TFSA lets your savings and investments grow tax-free. Here's who can open one, the 2026 limit, how withdrawals work and the mistakes that cost money.
- [How An RRSP Works In Canada](https://maplebudget.com/learn/how-an-rrsp-works.md): An RRSP lowers your tax now and taxes the money when you take it out. Here's the 2026 limit, the deadline, how withdrawals are taxed and a worked example.
- [TFSA Vs RRSP Vs FHSA: Which Account Comes First](https://maplebudget.com/learn/tfsa-vs-rrsp-vs-fhsa.md): How the TFSA, RRSP and FHSA compare on tax, limits and withdrawals in 2026, with a worked example of when each one comes out ahead.

All articles: https://maplebudget.com/learn.md
