Fixed Vs Variable Mortgage: Which Is Better?
A fixed rate locks your payment for the term. A variable rate moves with your lender's prime rate. See how the two compare on a $500,000 mortgage when rates hold or rise.
Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude to ask questions about it.
Updated Facts checked SourcesView As Markdown
A fixed-rate mortgage keeps the same rate and payment for your whole term, so you always know what you’ll pay. A variable-rate mortgage moves with your lender’s prime rate, so it can cost less if rates fall or hold and more if they rise. Neither is always better. Fixed buys certainty. Variable is a bet that you’ll come out ahead and can handle it if you don’t.
What It Is
Your mortgage rate is set for each term, often 5 years. You pick one of these when you sign:
- Fixed rate. The rate stays the same for the whole term. Your payments stay the same too.
- Variable rate. The rate can go up and down during the term. Lenders often price it as prime plus or minus a percentage, so it follows their prime rate.
- Hybrid or combination. Part of the mortgage is fixed and part is variable.
Variable mortgages come in two styles:
- Fixed payments. Your payment stays the same. When rates rise, more of it goes to interest and less to principal. If rates reach a trigger point, your lender may raise your payment.
- Adjustable payments. Your payment changes whenever the rate changes.
Key Rules
- Fixed rates are usually higher than variable rates when you sign, according to FCAC. That gap is the price of certainty.
- A variable rate can change any time during the term. Your rate isn’t locked until the term ends.
- Variable with fixed payments has a trigger point. Past it, your lender may increase your payments.
- You qualify the same way. The stress test uses 5.25% or your rate plus 2%, whichever is higher, for either type.
- Breaking the mortgage costs different amounts. Lenders often charge the higher of 3 months’ interest or the interest rate differential (IRD). FCAC notes the IRD usually applies when your rate is above today’s rates, and its own example comes to $12,000 on a $200,000 balance.
- Ask about conversion. Before you sign a variable mortgage, ask your lender whether you could switch to a fixed rate during the term, and on what terms.
A Worked Example
Morgan has a $500,000 mortgage with a 25-year amortization. The lender offers two 5-year options. The rates here are examples, not today’s market.
- Fixed at 4.5%: about $2,767 a month for all 5 years.
- Variable at 4.0%, adjustable payments: about $2,630 a month to start.
Here’s how the first 5 years play out in three situations.
Rates hold. The variable payment stays at $2,630. Over 5 years Morgan pays about $93,076 in interest, compared with about $105,024 on the fixed. Variable saves about $11,948.
Rates rise 1 point after the first year. The variable rate goes to 5.0% and the payment jumps to about $2,899. Interest over 5 years is about $111,835. That’s about $6,811 more than fixed.
Rates rise 1.5 points after the first year. The variable rate goes to 5.5% and the payment jumps to about $3,038. Interest over 5 years is about $121,251, about $16,227 more than fixed.
Morgan's Monthly Payment Over The 5-Year Term
Fixed 4.5%Variable, rates holdVariable, up to 5.0%Variable, up to 5.5%
Fixed at 4.5% is $2,767 a month for 60 months. Variable at 4.0% starts at $2,630. If the rate rises to 5.0% after 12 months, the payment rises to about $2,899. If it rises to 5.5%, the payment rises to about $3,038.
The chart’s y-axis starts at $2,400 so the differences are visible. The table below has the same numbers.
Interest Paid Over 5 Years On $500,000
Interest over five years: variable with rates holding about $93,076, fixed at 4.5% about $105,024, variable rising to 5.0% about $111,835, variable rising to 5.5% about $121,251.
The Three Situations Side By Side
| Option | Payment From Year 2 | 5-Year Interest | Balance After 5 Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed 4.5% | $2,767 | $105,024 | $438,982 |
| Variable, rates hold | $2,630 | $93,076 | $435,270 |
| Variable, up to 5.0% | $2,899 | $111,835 | $441,132 |
| Variable, up to 5.5% | $3,038 | $121,251 | $443,874 |
The real question for Morgan isn’t which line wins. It’s whether a $270 to $410 jump in the monthly payment would break the budget. If it would, the higher fixed rate is buying something real.
Questions To Help You Choose
- How much could your payment rise before it hurts? If a $300 jump would force you to miss other bills, fixed may be worth the higher rate.
- How long will you stay? If you might sell or refinance mid-term, compare the penalties as well as the rates.
- Do you have a buffer? An emergency fund makes a variable rate much less risky.
- Would you sleep better knowing the payment? Certainty has real value. It’s fine to pay for it.
The Short Answer
Choose fixed if a payment jump would strain your budget or if you value knowing exactly what you’ll pay. Consider variable if you have a buffer, you could absorb a higher payment, and you’re comfortable with the chance of paying more in exchange for the chance of paying less.
Common Mistakes
- Choosing on the starting rate alone. A lower rate today says nothing about the next 5 years.
- Not stress-testing your own budget. Ask what happens if your payment rises by $300 or $400 a month. If the answer is “I’d miss payments,” variable is risky for you.
- Ignoring the trigger point. With fixed payments, rising rates can quietly slow your progress on the principal until your lender steps in.
- Forgetting the penalty. If you might sell or refinance before the term ends, compare how each option’s penalty is calculated.
- Assuming fixed means the payment never changes. It’s fixed for the term. At renewal you get whatever rate is on offer then.
How Maple Budget Helps
Set your mortgage payment as a recurring transaction. If you’re on a variable rate with adjustable payments, update the amount when your lender tells you it’s changing. Your Home or Loans budget will show the new number right away.
Keep a buffer for rate rises. Give the Emergency Fund category a monthly budget so you’re saving toward it every month. If your payment ever jumps, you’ll see where the extra money has to come from. Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web.
This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your own numbers depend on your situation, so check with the CRA or an accountant before you act.
Common Questions
Are Variable Rates Always Lower?
Not always. FCAC says fixed rates are usually higher than variable rates, but the gap changes with the market. Sometimes the two are close, or variable is higher. Compare the actual offers you get.
What Is A Trigger Point?
With a variable rate and fixed payments, rising rates mean more of each payment goes to interest. If rates reach a certain level, called the trigger point, your lender may increase your payments. Your contract says where that point is.
Does A Fixed Rate Mean My Payment Never Changes?
It stays the same for the term. When the term ends you renew at whatever rate is on offer then, so your payment can go up or down at renewal.
Is A Hybrid Mortgage An Option?
Yes. Some lenders offer a combination mortgage where part of the balance has a fixed rate and part has a variable rate. It spreads the risk between the two.
Sources
Every number on this page was checked against these official pages.
- Interest On Mortgages (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Choosing A Mortgage (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Reducing Prepayment Penalties (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Preparing To Get A Mortgage (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
Try It In Maple Budget
Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web. One account works everywhere.
