Holding US Dollars And Norbert's Gambit
How Canadians can hold US dollars in an investment account, how Norbert's Gambit converts CAD to USD with DLR, and how to report US trades in Canadian dollars.
Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude to ask questions about it.
Updated Facts checked SourcesView As Markdown
Many Canadian brokers let you hold US dollars in the same account as Canadian dollars, so you can buy US stocks and ETFs without converting every time. Converting at your broker’s rate usually costs a spread, often 1.5% to 2.5%. Norbert’s Gambit is a way to convert for less: buy DLR in Canadian dollars, have your broker journal it to DLR.U, then sell DLR.U in US dollars.
What It Is
A US-dollar account, or the USD side of a registered or non-registered account, holds US cash and US-priced investments. When you buy a US stock with Canadian dollars, your broker converts the money first. That conversion has a cost built into the exchange rate you get.
Questrade’s guide puts typical retail conversion spreads at about 1.5% to 2.5% per transaction. On $10,000, that’s $150 to $250.
Norbert’s Gambit uses a security that trades in both currencies. DLR is an ETF priced in Canadian dollars, and DLR.U is the same ETF priced in US dollars. Because it’s the same security, your broker can move it from one side of your account to the other. This is called journalling. You buy in one currency and sell in the other, so the market prices do the converting. Some people use a large stock listed on both the TSX and a US exchange instead.
Key Rules
- It’s three trades and a request. Buy DLR in CAD, ask your broker to journal it to DLR.U, then sell DLR.U for USD. For USD to CAD, reverse it.
- Don’t sell before the journal is done. Selling first can leave a negative balance in your account.
- Use limit orders. A limit order sets your price, so a quick price swing can’t cost you.
- It takes time. Trades take time to settle, and journalling can take one to two more business days, depending on the broker.
- Costs shift, they don’t vanish. You pay any commissions and the bid-ask spreads on DLR and DLR.U instead of a conversion spread.
- Check your broker’s process. Some brokers journal online. Others need a phone call or chat. Some may hold the funds until it’s done.
- It’s taxable in a non-registered account. Each sale is a disposition, so small gains or losses can come up. Report them in Canadian dollars.
- US trades are reported in Canadian dollars. For any US stock, convert the cost at the exchange rate on the day you bought and the proceeds at the rate on the day you sold. The CRA points to Bank of Canada rates.
- Holding USD is a currency bet. If the Canadian dollar rises, your US holdings are worth less in Canadian dollars, even if their US price doesn’t change.
Norbert's Gambit With DLR, Canadian To US Dollars
- 1Buy DLR in Canadian dollarsUse a limit order on the Canadian side of your account.
- 2Wait for the trade to fillCheck the confirmation and keep it for your records.
- 3Ask your broker to journal DLR to DLR.USome brokers do this online. Others need a call or a chat.
- 4Sell DLR.U in US dollarsOnly after the journal is done, again with a limit order.
A Worked Example
Jason has $10,000 in Canadian dollars in his non-registered account in Toronto. He wants US dollars to buy a US-listed ETF.
Step 1. Price the easy way. If his broker’s conversion spread is 1.5%, converting directly costs about $150. At 2.5%, about $250.
Cost Of A Typical Conversion Spread On $10,000
A 1.5% spread on $10,000 costs $150. A 2.5% spread costs $250.
Step 2. Buy DLR. He places a limit order and buys DLR on the Canadian side of his account with his $10,000.
Step 3. Journal. Once the trade fills, he asks his broker to journal his DLR units to DLR.U on the US side.
Step 4. Sell DLR.U. When the journal is done, he sells DLR.U with a limit order and has US dollars in his account. His cost was the commissions, if any, and the bid-ask spreads, instead of the 1.5% to 2.5% spread.
Step 5. Track the tax side. Because this is a non-registered account, the DLR.U sale is a disposition. He keeps the trade confirmations so he can report any small gain or loss in Canadian dollars.
Step 6. Report a later US trade in CAD. Later, he buys 10 shares of a US stock at US$100, when US$1 costs $1.35 Canadian. His cost is $1,350. He sells them at US$120, when US$1 costs $1.30. His proceeds are $1,560. His gain is $210 in Canadian dollars, not US$200. These rates are made up, but the method is the CRA’s.
A US Stock, Converted To Canadian Dollars
| US dollars | Rate | Canadian dollars | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buy 10 shares at US$100 | US$1,000 | 1.35 | $1,350 |
| Sell 10 shares at US$120 | US$1,200 | 1.30 | $1,560 |
| Gain | US$200 | $210 |
Common Mistakes
- Buying DLR.U instead of DLR. The tickers are close. Buy DLR with Canadian dollars and sell DLR.U for US dollars.
- Trading on the wrong currency side. If you buy a US stock on the CAD side, your broker may convert automatically at its own rate.
- Selling before the journal finishes. Wait for your broker to confirm.
- Using market orders. A market order on a thin moment can cost more than the spread you were avoiding.
- Doing it for small amounts. For a few hundred dollars, a commission can wipe out the savings.
- Using one exchange rate for a whole US trade. The buy and the sell each use the rate from their own day.
- Converting back and forth. If you’ll buy US investments again, keep the US dollars.
How Maple Budget Helps
Maple Finance lets you set an investment account’s currency to CAD, USD or GBP in the app, plus EUR on the web. When you log a USD trade in the app, fill in FX Rate (Optional) with that day’s rate. The Taxes page then works out your Adjusted Cost Base in Canadian dollars at each trade’s own rate, the way the CRA asks. If a USD trade has no rate on file, Maple warns you that today’s rate was used, so you can add the right one.
In Settings, Show Totals In lets you see your whole portfolio in CAD or USD, converted at live exchange rates. The Allocation card’s Currency view shows how much you hold in each. See change your currency and add your investments.
Maple Finance comes with Maple Pro, which starts with a 7-day free trial. This is general information. Check your broker’s own steps before you try Norbert’s Gambit.
This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your own numbers depend on your situation, so check with the CRA or an accountant before you act.
Common Questions
Is Norbert's Gambit Legal?
Yes. It's just buying a security, moving it to the other currency side of your account and selling it. Many Canadian brokers support it. Each step is a normal trade.
Is Norbert's Gambit Worth It For Small Amounts?
Often not. It replaces a currency spread with commissions and bid-ask spreads, and it takes a few business days. For a few hundred dollars, the savings may not be worth the effort.
Do I Have To Report Norbert's Gambit On My Taxes?
In a non-registered account, yes. Selling DLR.U is a disposition, so there can be a small capital gain or loss to report in Canadian dollars. In a TFSA or RRSP, there's nothing to report.
Should I Keep US Dollars Or Convert Back?
If you'll buy US investments again, keeping US dollars in a USD account avoids paying to convert twice. Holding USD also means your value in Canadian dollars moves with the exchange rate.
Sources
Every number on this page was checked against these official pages.
- Norbert's Gambit: How Currency Conversion Works (Questrade), checked November 17, 2026
- Capital Gains 2025, Guide T4037 (CRA), checked November 17, 2026
- Line 40500, Federal Foreign Tax Credit (CRA), checked November 17, 2026
- Exchange Rates (Bank Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Why Does Risk Matter In Investing? (Ontario Securities Commission, GetSmarterAboutMoney.ca), checked November 17, 2026
Try It In Maple Budget
Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web. One account works everywhere.
