Rent Vs Buy: How To Decide In Canada
Buying isn't always cheaper than renting. Compare the costs you never get back on each side, plus the cash buying ties up, with a worked Ontario condo example.
Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude to ask questions about it.
Updated Facts checked SourcesView As Markdown
Buying beats renting when the costs you never get back as an owner, like mortgage interest, property tax, condo fees and repairs, are close to or below your rent, and you’ll stay long enough to cover the one-time costs of buying. Renting can win when those owner costs are higher, when you might move within a few years, or when you’d rather keep your savings flexible.
What It Is
The rent vs buy question isn’t “rent or mortgage payment.” Part of each mortgage payment pays down your loan, which you keep as equity. The fair comparison is between the money that’s gone for good on each side.
When you rent, the main costs you don’t get back are rent and tenant insurance.
When you own, the costs you don’t get back include:
- Mortgage interest.
- Property tax.
- Condo fees, if you buy a condo.
- Home insurance.
- Maintenance and repairs.
- One-time costs to buy and, later, to sell.
Owning also ties up your down payment. That money could have stayed invested if you rented. Whether the home or the investments grow faster is unknown in advance, which is why there’s no single right answer.
Key Rules
- Housing costs have limits. FCAC suggests keeping rent and household costs under 35% of gross income. For owners, lenders cap housing costs at 39% of gross income. See how much house you can afford.
- Buying takes cash up front. A minimum down payment of at least 5%, plus closing costs of 1.5% to 4% of the price.
- Ontario charges land transfer tax. On a $650,000 home it’s $9,475. First-time buyers can get up to $4,000 back.
- Renters in older Ontario units get capped increases. The guideline is 2.1% for 2026 and 1.9% for 2027. Most units first occupied after November 15, 2018 are exempt.
- Owners carry the risk of repairs. A new roof or furnace is your bill.
- You must qualify. Lenders test your payments at 5.25% or your rate plus 2%, whichever is higher.
A Worked Example
Casey rents a two-bedroom in Ontario for $2,600 a month and pays $25 for tenant insurance. A similar condo nearby costs $650,000. Casey has $160,000 saved and is a first-time buyer. All the costs below are example numbers for this walkthrough.
If Casey buys with 20% down ($130,000), the mortgage is $520,000. At an example rate of 4.5% over 25 years, the payment is about $2,878. Casey also pays $300 a month in property tax, $600 in condo fees, $50 for insurance and sets aside $200 for repairs.
Monthly cash out. Owning costs about $4,028 a month. Renting costs $2,625.
Casey's Monthly Cash Out
Owning costs about $4,028 a month in cash: $2,878 mortgage, $300 property tax, $600 condo fees, $50 insurance and $200 for repairs. Renting costs $2,625: $2,600 rent and $25 tenant insurance.
Costs Casey never gets back. In the first year, about $1,912 a month of the mortgage payment is interest. The other $966 pays down the loan. So the owner’s unrecoverable costs are about $1,912 of interest, plus $300 tax, $600 fees, $50 insurance and $200 repairs. That’s about $3,062 a month, against $2,625 for renting.
Monthly Costs Casey Never Gets Back, Year One
Rent or interestTax and feesInsurance and repairs
Renting: $2,600 rent and $25 insurance, $2,625 in total. Owning: $1,912 interest, $300 property tax, $600 condo fees, $50 insurance and $200 repairs, $3,062 in total.
Up-front cash. Buying also takes cash on day one.
Cash Casey Needs To Buy The $650,000 Condo
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Down payment, 20% | $130,000 |
| Ontario land transfer tax | $9,475 |
| First-time buyer refund | -$4,000 |
| Legal fees (example) | $2,000 |
| Home inspection (example) | $500 |
| Total | $137,975 |
What it means. On these numbers, buying costs Casey about $437 a month more in lost money, plus a one-time hit of about $8,000 in closing costs. In return, Casey gets stable housing, control over the home and any rise in its value. If the condo’s value grows and Casey stays many years, buying can come out ahead. If prices are flat or Casey moves in 3 years, renting probably wins.
Questions To Ask Yourself
- How long will I stay? The longer you stay, the more time there is to spread out buying and selling costs.
- Is my income stable? A mortgage is a long commitment, and repairs don’t wait for a good month.
- Do I have savings left after closing? Buying with every dollar you have leaves no cushion.
- What do I want from a home? Control, stability and the chance to renovate are real benefits that don’t show up in the math.
The Bottom Line
There’s no rule that says owning beats renting. Owning makes most sense when you’ll stay for years, your income is steady, and the costs you never get back are close to rent. Renting makes sense when you might move, when owning costs much more each month, or when you’d rather keep your savings flexible and invested. Run your own numbers with real quotes before you decide.
Common Mistakes
- Comparing rent to the full mortgage payment. The principal part isn’t a cost. It’s savings you keep.
- Leaving out repairs and condo fees. They’re real costs every month, even if a repair hasn’t happened yet.
- Forgetting the one-time costs. Land transfer tax, legal fees and, later, selling costs all eat into any gain.
- Ignoring what the down payment could earn. Cash in a home isn’t free. It could have grown somewhere else.
- Buying for a short stay. The one-time costs need years to spread out.
How Maple Budget Helps
The best test is a real one. If you’re renting and thinking of buying, budget as if you already owned. Put your rent in the Rent category and move the difference between rent and the estimated owning cost into Savings each month with a recurring transaction. If you can do that for six months, you know the payment fits, and you’ve grown your down payment.
Category budgets show where the money goes, and Maple Wrapped recaps each month. Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web.
This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your own numbers depend on your situation, so check with the CRA or an accountant before you act.
Common Questions
Isn't Rent Just Throwing Money Away?
Rent buys you a place to live, just like mortgage interest, property tax and condo fees do for an owner. Compare the costs you never get back on both sides, not rent against the whole mortgage payment.
How Long Should I Plan To Stay If I Buy?
Long enough for the gains to outweigh the one-time costs of buying and selling. Closing costs alone are often 1.5% to 4% of the price, and selling has its own costs. The shorter your stay, the harder buying is to justify.
Does Rent Control Change The Math?
It can. In Ontario, most units first occupied before November 15, 2018 have yearly increases capped by the rent increase guideline, which is 2.1% for 2026 and 1.9% for 2027. Newer units are exempt.
Sources
Every number on this page was checked against these official pages.
- Buying A Home (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Renting An Apartment Or House (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Preparing To Get A Mortgage (Financial Consumer Agency Of Canada), checked November 17, 2026
- Calculating Land Transfer Tax (Ontario), checked November 17, 2026
- Land Transfer Tax Refunds For First-Time Homebuyers (Ontario), checked November 17, 2026
- Rent Increase Guideline (Ontario), checked November 17, 2026
Try It In Maple Budget
Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web. One account works everywhere.
