Is A Balance Transfer Worth It?

A balance transfer moves card debt to a new card with a low promotional rate. It's worth it if the fee is less than the interest you save and you pay it down in time.

Paste it into ChatGPT or Claude to ask questions about it.

Updated Facts checked SourcesView As Markdown

A balance transfer is worth it when the transfer fee is less than the interest you’d save, and you can pay the balance off, or most of it, before the low promotional rate ends. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada says these intro rates are usually lower or 0% and usually last 6 to 18 months. If you keep spending on the old card, or miss a payment and lose the promo rate, it can cost you more than it saves.

What It Is

A balance transfer moves what you owe on one credit card to another card, usually a new one with a lower rate for a limited time. The FCAC describes it as moving your balance from an old card to a new one that generally has a lower rate.

The catch is in three places: the fee to move the money, the length of the promotion, and the rate you pay after it ends.

Key Rules

  • There’s usually a fee. The FCAC says the balance transfer fee is usually a percentage of the amount you transfer.
  • The low rate is temporary. The FCAC says the intro rate is usually 6 to 18 months. Read your offer for the exact end date and for the rate that applies after.
  • Miss a payment, lose the rate. The FCAC says you may lose your promotional rate if you miss a payment.
  • Minimums still apply. You still have to make the minimum payment every month.
  • No grace period on transfers. The FCAC says the grace period doesn’t apply to balance transfers. Interest, at whatever rate applies, starts right away.
  • Applying is a hard inquiry. A new card means an application. The FCAC warns that applying with several lenders may lower your score.
  • It doesn’t fix spending. The FCAC says if you keep the spending habits that caused the debt, you’ll build up more.

A Worked Example

Grace owes $6,000 on a card at 20.99%. She can pay $400 a month. She gets an offer: move the balance to a new card at 0% for 12 months, with a 3% transfer fee. After 12 months, the rate on what’s left goes to 20.99%. Her offer states that rate. Yours may differ.

We worked both out month by month with interest at the annual rate divided by 12. Real cards charge interest daily, so real totals land a little differently.

Stay on the old card. At $400 a month, it takes 18 months. Interest comes to $1,020.74.

Move it. The 3% fee adds $180, so she owes $6,180 on the new card. For 12 months at 0%, every $400 goes to the balance. After a year, $1,380 is left. That rolls to 20.99% and takes 4 more months, with $56.64 of interest. Fee plus interest: $236.64.

Grace's $6,000 At $400 A Month

$6,000 paid at $400 a month. Staying on the card at 20.99%: 1 year and 6 months and $1,020.74 of interest. Moving it with a $180 fee to 0% for 12 months, then 20.99%: 1 year and 4 months and $236.64 in fee and interest.

Moving the balance saves her $784.10, as long as she makes every payment and doesn't add to either card.

What Grace Pays On Top Of The $6,000

Stay on the card (18 months): $1,020.74. Balance transfer (16 months, fee plus interest): $236.64.

The $180 fee is far less than the interest she'd pay staying put.

The transfer saves Grace $784.10 and finishes two months sooner. If she could pay $515 a month, she’d clear the whole $6,180 inside the 12 months and pay only the $180 fee.

Now the version that goes wrong. Grace moves the balance but keeps using her old card, and misses one payment on the new card in month 5. She may lose the 0% rate on the new card, and the old card fills back up at 20.99%. Now she has two balances instead of one.

Is The Transfer Worth It For You?

QuestionWhy it matters
Is the fee less than the interest you would save?The fee is paid up front, whether or not you finish
Can you pay most of it off before the promo ends?What is left goes to the regular rate
Will you set up automatic payments?A missed payment may cost you the promo rate
Will you stop using the old card?Otherwise you end up with two balances
If you can answer yes to all four, the numbers usually work in your favour.

Common Mistakes

  • Ignoring the fee. A 3% fee on a balance you’d have paid off in three months anyway can cost more than it saves.
  • Not knowing the end date or the rate after. Put the date in your calendar. Know what rate the leftover balance will get.
  • Spending on the old card. The freed-up limit is tempting. This is how one debt becomes two.
  • Missing a payment. Set the minimum, or better, your plan amount, to pay automatically.
  • Using the new card for purchases without reading the terms. Your agreement explains how purchases and payments are treated alongside a promo balance. Read it before you buy anything on that card.

How Maple Budget Helps

A balance transfer only works with a steady payment, every month, until the promotion ends. Maple Budget helps you protect that payment. Give each spending category a monthly budget so you can see what’s left for the card. Add both cards as payment methods, and on iPhone or Android filter Transactions by card. If anything new shows up on the old card, you’ll see it right away.

Budgeting is free. With Maple Pro ($1.99 a week, 7-day free trial) you can connect your bank and cards so every purchase fills in on its own.

This is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Your own numbers depend on your situation, so check with the CRA or an accountant before you act.

Common Questions

How Long Do Balance Transfer Promotions Last?

The FCAC says introductory rates usually last 6 to 18 months. Your offer states the exact length.

Is There A Fee For A Balance Transfer?

Usually. The FCAC says the fee is usually a percentage of the amount you transfer. Add it to the cost before you decide.

Can I Lose The Promotional Rate?

Yes. The FCAC says you may lose the promotional rate if you miss a payment. You still have to make the minimum payment every month.

Does A Balance Transfer Hurt My Credit Score?

Applying for a new card is a hard inquiry. Paying the balance down afterwards lowers your credit utilization, which can help.

Sources

Every number on this page was checked against these official pages.

Try It In Maple Budget

Budgeting is free on iPhone, Android and the web. One account works everywhere.